Ringside 1925:
Views from the Scopes Trial
by Jen Bryant

    RINGSIDE 1925 by Jen Bryant
    Category:  Historical
    Age Recommendation:  Grades 6+
    Release Date:  2/12/08
    Publisher:  Knopf
    Reviewed by:  Natalie Tsang
    Rating:  4 Stars


    Jen Bryant’s RINGSIDE 1925 explores the Scopes Trial, one of the most controversial trials in American history,
    through nine diverse characters and is told through vivid verse.

    One memorable summer, the sleepy town of Dayton, Tennessee, population 1,800, is turned upside down by the trial
    of a well-liked high school teacher.  His crime is teaching evolution, a subject that the state of Tennessee had
    forbidden in the newly passed Butler Law.  

    William Jennings Bryan, a talented orator, preacher, and three time presidential nominee, will speak against evolution,
    and Clarence Darrow, a brilliant lawyer, comes to defend Mr. Scopes.

    News of the trial spreads quickly and, almost overnight, the town fills with news reporters, scientists, religious leaders,
    and tourists. Many residents, such as twelve-year-old Willy Amos and drugstore owner Mr. Robinson, see it as an
    opportunity to make some quick easy money.  Since Darwin’s theory of evolution suggests that man evolved from
    monkeys, Dayton begins selling everything from paper monkeys to Simian Sodas.  

    At first, the atmosphere is friendly and fun.  Though they are on opposing sides of the “monkey trial,” W. J. Bryan and
    Mr. Darrow are friends and share a dinner together at Tillie Stackhouse’s boarding house.  But as the trial drags on in
    the muggy summer weather, tensions rise.  Not only do the two men’s friendship become strained, but many of the
    residents become embroiled in the increasingly bitter God vs. science debate.

    Many young readers may have learned about the Scopes Trial in school, but Bryant brings a new level of relevance by
    telling the story primarily through the eyes of Dayton’s residents and observing the smaller but no less significant
    changes to a small town in addition to the broad historical significance.  

    Jimmy Lee Davis and Peter Sykes have been fishing buddies and best friends for years, but their personal beliefs lead
    them to support opposite sides of the trial. Marybeth Todd is a smart but restless teenager. When several professors
    come to stay at the boarding house she works at, they ask her to participate in their discussions of geology,
    anthropology, and other unfamiliar and wonderful topics. The influx of visitors brings in money, but also new ideas and
    opportunities.

    Readers who usually dislike historical fiction will find Bryant’s characters fresh, familiar, often insightful, and sometimes
    silly.  The story feels real and full-fleshed, but never gets bogged down by its research.